Link: True Irish - Timothy Egan - Op-Extra Columnist - Opinion - New York Times Blog.
A few lifts:
And more than once you will hear this Irish saying: “If you want to know what God thinks of money, just look at who he gives it to.”
and
“The thing about the Irish,” he said, “is that we have always been there for the little guy. We go through life as underdogs. We die as underdogs. There is no other way for the Irish.”
It isn't right to blame God for unjust manmade systems. And if we think it important to create a society with no victims -- and conversely, symmetrically, with no windfalls, no free lunches -- we need to understand the structural reasons for the poverty we see around us. God didn't create poverty. We do. Day in and day out. God didn't create slavery either; men did, and men ended it in this country, in its most obvious form, anyway.
Here's the comment I posted on the NYT blog:
I commend to your attention Henry George's book "The Irish Land Question," published in 1881. For all who would like to understand the underlying dynamics that sent so many Americans' ancestors from Ireland to the US, this short book, available online under its later title -- The Land Question -- can provide a clear understanding. [The retitling was in recognition of the universality -- and timelessness -- of what was most visible in Ireland.]
It is very much worth a read in 2008, and not just for those of Irish ancestry or with an interest in history!
And here are the chapter headings:
Ch. 1: Unpalatable Truth
Ch. 2: Distress and Famine
Ch. 3: A Universal Question
Ch. 4: Proposed Remedies
Ch. 5: Whose Land is it?
Ch. 6: Landlords' Right is Labor's Wrong
Ch. 7: The Great-Great-Grandson of Captain Kidd
Ch. 8: The Only Way, the Easy Way
Ch. 9: Principle the Best Policy
Ch. 10: Appeals to Animosity
Ch. 11: How to Win
Ch. 12: In the United States
Ch. 13: A little Island or a little World
Ch. 14: The Civilization that is Possible
Ch. 15: The Civilization that is
Ch. 16: True Conservatism
Ch. 17: In Hoc Signo Vinces
The book is available at http://www.wealthandwant.com/HG/irish_land_question.html. When I previewed it for printing, it was just 27 pages.
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.