StamfordCT

Fortunes Made in Real Estate

Americans have a tendency to respect those who are "self-made men." This seems to include people whose fortunes have been made in real estate.  The latest example in the news is the outgoing governor of New York, whose father, Bernard Spitzer, reportedly has a $500 million portfolio of properties, most or all in NYC.

I have nothing against real estate developers in their role as developers.  They bring large amounts of money and multiple talents to bear to create new modern buildings on sites previously occupied by more modest buildings suitable to another decade or century. And when they build they generally create the venues in which dozens, even hundreds, of entrepreneurial visions can be made into reality, and where thousands, sometimes tens of thousands, of people can be employed in a single building.  Appropriate development of choice sites, served by existing infrastructure such as NYC's elaborate transportation system and things as prosaic as city water, sanitary sewers, stormwater runoff, and all the other systems that are paid for by we-the-people: schools, public safety, public health, libraries, courts, hospitals, etc., means that specialized work can take in the center of the central business district, conducted by people who come from a 360 degree radius.  It minimizes sprawl on the fringe, and makes the economy work more smoothly.

But there are other facets of the real estate business that I think are "opportunities for plunder" that should be restructured to serve the common good instead of the private good.  This involves a revision of our notions of what is right, what is just, what is rightly private property and what legitimately belongs to the commons.

Affordable housing -- for all of us. What policies promote it?

Link: http://www.sun-herald.com/Newsstory.cfm?pubdate=030808&story=tp1ch5.htm&folder=NewsArchive2

A front-page article in the 3/8/08 Charlotte (County, FL) Sun entitled "Not Affordable Enough" speaks to some interesting and important issues regarding Florida's housing.  A few excerpts:

The current downturn in residential real estate sales has created the closest thing to a buyer's market Florida has seen since the 1990s.

While that might be great news for a Northern couple looking to retire in Punta Gorda or Port Charlotte with their life savings, Charlotte County's median home price -- about $175,000 according to recent Florida Association of Realtors figures -- is still a barrier for many local wage earners ...

Despite North Port's reputation as a haven for working families, the median sale price in the Sarasota-Bradenton market remains about $260,000

Referring to recent problems in the housing market,

"It's a blip on the screen really, and in a year, we're going to be thankful that we did some investing in affordable housing," said Ron Thomas, executive director of Enterprise Punta Gorda, the city's economic development bureau. "When everybody says that there's plenty of affordable housing, we have to qualify that by saying that there is plenty of affordable housing for people who are in the 80 percent or above the median income. This doesn't have any positive effect for anybody in the 30 to 80 percent median income bracket."

"Even as low as (housing) has come down, it still might not suit firefighters, police, and school teachers. They're still struggling," said Bill Albers, Punta Gorda city councilman. Albers is the council's liaison to the Punta Gorda Housing Authority.

Closet Georgists and Georgites: Bill Buckley, and others

Link: Jay Nordlinger on Impromptus on National Review Online.

Since Bill Buckley died a few weeks ago, I've read numerous tributes, and a few have mentioned Buckley's abiding interest in the ideas of Henry George.  The newest reference comes from the opening paragraphs of a National Review article today:

Friends, a week ago I put some notes on WFB in Impromptus. (That column is here.) Want a few more notes? Just a few more?

You know that he loved peanut butter. Ate it every morning of his life. Took it everywhere he went (because sometimes you couldn’t get it). But did you also know he had a thing for coffee ice cream? Yes — a real jones for it. I introduced him to Ben & Jerry’s Coffee Heath Bar Crunch — one of the best things on the planet.

(Yes, I know that they are communists or whatever. Just eat the ice cream.)

Note 2: Years ago, I had a spot of trouble finding housing in Manhattan. And he said to me, “Do you know I’m a closet George-ite?” He meant the 19th-century American economist and social thinker Henry George (author of Progress and Poverty).

How I wish that Bill Buckley, and others whose education was good enough to include exposure to the ideas of Henry George, had left/would leave their closets.  (Perhaps the reason has something to do with something related to pluralistic ignorance; perhaps it is something more nefarious.)

Bill Buckley did mention Henry George repeatedly in his writings and on the air, but in passing, as if to run it up the flag pole, rather than as a confident advocate of an idea that might not be popular with his constituency. 

Financing Municipal Spending through Sales Taxes: an Inferior "Solution"

Chicago will soon have the highest sales tax of any major city in the US.  Not the highest sales tax in the US -- there is a town in northeastern Alabama, Arab, which imposes sales taxes as high as 12% -- but the highest of any major city.  (Alabama's sales taxes -- designed to place the maximum burden on poor people, while making life easier for upper-income residents, particularly the property-owners -- typically tax even groceries!)   An AP article reports:

Among the things Chicago wants to be known for, having the highest total sales taxes of any major U.S. city is probably not one of them.

But that's what it's getting after the Cook County Board voted Saturday to double the county sales tax to 1.75 percent. When added to the city's sales tax, the county' increase has the cumulative effect of setting a 10.25 percent sales tax on goods bought in Chicago.

When the county rate increase takes effect in November, someone buying $100 worth of merchandise in Chicago would pay $110.25.

The rates in New York and Los Angeles are below 8.5 percent. The next highest rate in the country is in Memphis, Tenn., at 9.25 percent.

The tax increase is expected to add about $426 million annually to county coffers, and the money is meant to close a projected $234 million deficit. The budget is also designed to create more than 1,000 new county jobs.

Private (homeowner) Associations, their Private Beaches, and the Local Assessor

I live in a small city within easy commuting distance of New York City.  It includes some lovely waterfront communities (with property values to match), a downtown with many corporations, a 1- and 2-acre zone, neighborhoods that include children who collectively speak 30 or more different languages and many whose families live below the "self-sufficiency level", multiple high schools, a few magnet schools.

There are a number of subdivisions which have some common property, and it turns out that the local assessor has been very generous with them.  Is this legitimate, or is it a privilege (private law, for the benefit of a few at the expense of the rest of the community)?   I can't see how it is anything but a privilege, a free lunch for special people. (To which I say, eschew privilege!!)

I'll start with the waterfront communities.  There are several of them.  Within one, there are are several private associations.  No gates, no signs, except the "no trespassing" signs on their private beaches; other than the beach signs and the real estate ads, which invariably mention "deeded beach rights," they don't seem any different from other streets on their peninsula.  But each of the three sub-neighborhoods has some private property on the waterfront.   

Downtown Sprawl, Property Assessments and Getting the Incentives Right

I live in small city within commuting distance of New York City. For the 32 years I've been here, there has been a 4.3 acre hole-in-the-ground within about 1/4 mile of the city's "100% location."  It is surrounded by a chain link fence, and bordered by a shopping mall, a hotel, some apartments and some office buildings.  It is within walking distance of a major railroad station and two interstate highway exits.   It is even identified in the city's assessment database as the hole in the ground.  It has weed trees and concrete-lined puddles.  I seem to recall that at least one person has drowned when their car ended up in deep water on the property.

When I moved here, the tallest building in town was 22 stories. Today, the tallest building is still that 22-story office building.  It sits a bit to the north of the geographic center of downtown.  We currently have under construction a 37-story luxury condo complex ... on 1/2 acre at the northwest corner of the downtown ... and a 39-story hotel and condo complex on 3 acres, solidly in the downtown area and close to the highway and railroad.

The Effects of a Phase-In of the Revaluation

The 2006 revaluation was phased in, in order not to overburden some people whose previous valuations had been low and had since risen. 

The phase-in was based on 80% of the old valuation -- which, if I 'm not mistaken was basically the 1999 valuations -- plus 20% of the 10/1/2006 valuation.  The correctness of the new valuation was barely considered.  We stuck mostly with data we knew to be seriously out of date

The 2006 valuation had its flaws, the most prominent of which was that it undervalued commercial property.  But it accounted for the huge appreciation in certain neighborhoods -- those which have access to Long Island Sound in particular -- and certain kinds of properties -- former single-family homes that have been subdivided into multifamily  rentals until the owner can sell them as teardowns.

Connecticut: Should Cities Use a Sales Tax?

Newspapers in New London ("Urban Mayors Push For Local Sales-tax Option") and Stamford ("Malloy: Cities should have sales tax option") had articles today describing 4 Connecticut cities' mayors' aversion to increasing the property tax.

Four urban mayors, including Kevin Cavanagh of New London, urged the legislature Monday to give municipalities the ability to levy a local sales tax of up to 1 percentage point to raise revenue without resorting to property-tax increases.

The articles quote Dannell Malloy of Stamford, Kevin Cavanagh of New London, Bill Finch of Bridgeport, and Dan DeStefano of New Haven as endorsing the idea.

Malloy, along with mayors Bill Finch of Bridgeport, John DeStefano of New Haven and Kevin Cavanagh of New London, said cities need other options for raising revenue besides burdening constituents with more property taxes.

City, suburb or rural?

I had a call from a polling organization last night; my phone number had been randomly selected, and I was the adult in the family whose birthday occurred next.  One of the questions, for classification purposes, was whether I lived in a city, a suburb or a rural area.  I puzzled over it a little.  Stamford is certainly a city, at 120,000 population.  But much of its character comes from its situation as a suburb of NYC.  And where I live, the neighborhood association seeks to maintain the "rural character" of the area.